Originally published at: https://discgolf.ultiworld.com/2018/10/17/circle-2uesday-major-headache/
A week ago I stumbled across a discussion on the disc golf subreddit that piqued my interest.
Under the header “USDGC vs Worlds,” user haonrek asked, “Beginner question here…which one of these tournaments is seen as more prestigious and why?”
Amidst the various anonymous replies, Danny Lindahl, Team Dynamic Discs member and DD employee known for his YouTube tutorials, weighed in twice in favor of Worlds. Here’s the meat of what he had to say (you can read his full comments on Reddit).
“Who [says] that USDGC is more prestigious than worlds? Signature discs come from world championships. ‘1x 2x 4x’ comes from world championships. . . . You can bet that if you ask Jerm [Jeremy Koling] and Nate [Sexton] which is more prestigious they’ll say worlds. Not that they would trade their US titles for a world title, but they’ll both say worlds is a more prestigious title (sic).”
Lindahl got me thinking. Excepting its 37-year pedigree, why is it that we privilege Worlds, a major, over the USDGC, also a major? Or the United States Women’s Disc Golf Championship, on the women’s side?When consulting the annals of golf and tennis – true Grand Slam sports – total majors always outweigh specific championships. I’m pretty sure that golf legend Jack Nicklaus doesn’t sign his name “3x” based on his record at the longest running major, the Open Championship (i.e. the British Open). If the pundits levied judgment based solely on this metric, six-time winner Harry Varden (1870-1937) would rank number one in the history books and the Golden Bear would tie for eleventh.
Nicklaus is considered by many to be the G.O.A.T. because he won 18 major championships: six Masters, five PGA Championships, four U.S. Opens, three Open Championships. The fact that he still holds this distinction despite ranking third in total victories behind Sam Snead and Tiger Woods speaks to the importance of this tally.
Total majors. This is how I want to talk about disc golf.
Ken Climo still reigns supreme as the winningest disc golfer in history with 20 major titles in the Open Division: twelve World Championships, five USDGCs, two Japan Opens, one European Open. Valarie Jenkins is second with 16, Paul McBeth third with 13, and Paige Pierce fourth with 11. These are the only four players who have won greater than ten major titles. Three players tied for fifth with seven victories: Dave Feldberg, Elaine King, and Des Reading.
We don’t talk like this because we don’t trust the younger majors. And for good reason. The lineup seems always in flux apart from the stalwarts. Even the USDGC has proven untrustworthy. Remember the lost year? In 2011, Innova scrapped the Open division in favor of a handicapped performance flight.
Since 1982, 13 tournaments have received major designation by the PDGA, including four one-off majors in the last decade, totally undermining the notion of a repeatable Grand Slam. Year-to-year, the number of majors often changes as well. There were five Open Division championships when McBeth ran the table in 2015, three in 2016, four in 2017, and three this year.((I suppose I should technically count the 2016 PDGA/WFDF Team Disc Golf World Championships, but no. Just no.))
Let’s review the slate, shall we? In order of their inception, the 13 majors include:
[table id=123 /]
It’s worth noting that golf and tennis codified their major slate over the course of decades:
The PGA took 74 years: The Open Championship (1860), the US Open in (1895), the PGA Championship in (1916), and the Masters in (1934).
Tennis took 38 years: Wimbledon (1884), US Open (1887), French Open (1897), and Australian Open (1922).
The LPGA has gone through four iterations of the major calendar and displays similar growing pains to the PDGA. Currently boasting five majors, three carry greater historic pedigree: The U.S. Women’s Open (1946), the LPGA Championship/Women’s PGA Championship (1955, name change in 2013), and the Nabisco Dinah Shore/Kraft Nabisco Championship/ANA Inspiration (1983, name changes in 2001 & 2013).
Professional disc golf needs to codify a consistent major lineup – I vote 4 per year – because it regulates the tour and establishes a historical precedent. Barring a dramatic change to the PDGA schedule, 2019 will be another lean year majors front. Fortunately, the return of the European Open makes the trio feel more prestigious than the 2018 crop.
Here’s one idea. Traverse the Atlantic in the odd years for the biennial European Open, and hop the Pacific in the even years. Reinstall the Japan Open to alternate with the Aussie Open every two years. The Japan Open clearly has the prestige-factor seeing as it ranks fourth in total iterations among the Majors, but neither it nor the Aussie Open has demonstrated true staying power. Let them share the load.
So that’s three events. For the fourth? Develop a West Coast major to be contested in late spring. Test some courses. Test some formats. Develop a ten-year plan toward this goal. At this point, it’s less about the specific details and more about establishing the basic groundwork.
If we lengthened the major championship season, fixed recurring tournament dates in the schedule, and standardized the four-event Grand Slam, the tour would naturally flow in and out of these championships more gracefully. After all, the majors are just another tour stop at their core, not the be-all end-all. A single tournament, no matter its history, cannot define greatness. As fans, we can begin shifting our mindset away from ranking the prestige of the individual majors and emphasizing their collective worth instead.